Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
Pizzaiola in North Babylon
Open
10:30 am
Monday
10:30 am
Wednesday
10:30 am
Friday
10:30 am
Sunday
10:30 am
1162 Deer Park Ave, Nortd Babylon, NY 11703-3102
Privilege
Cuisine
- Italian
- Pizza
- Vegetarian Friendly
Features
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Reservations
- Seating
- Wheelchair Accessible
- Serves Alcohol
- Waitstaff
- Highchairs Available
Good for
- Families witd children
- Kids
Privilege
Cuisine
- Italian
- Pizza
- Vegetarian Friendly
Features
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Reservations
- Seating
- Wheelchair Accessible
- Serves Alcohol
- Waitstaff
- Highchairs Available
Good for
- Families witd children
- Kids
Questions and answers
do you deliver??
Reviews
11/24/2024
On google
Cindy
The food was great I should really say it's a 5 but they took away angel hair pasta I'm very upset
More
Df
08/17/2020
On google
David feuer
This place has gradually been going downhill. They took emphasis off of quality to cater to quantity. Been going here for 7 years since I moved to the area. I had my last meal there a couple weeks ago. Will not be going back. Disappointed.
More
AR
08/17/2020
On google
Alana Roman
Great food!! Been going here for years. Best pizza Italian food in Babylon. My family has tried other places in the area but Pizzaiola is the best! Definitely try it!! Staff is always very friendly they know our first names. Never had a problem in the 5 years going here.
More
08/17/2020
On google
HardrockGX
Good food, good working crew, good atmosphere especially when it starts getting cold..
More
JO
08/17/2020
On google
Jill Oron
Good food but Extremely Overpriced...Only eat there when it's convenient for me to do so, economically speaking... Over $3.00 for a slice of pizza really?
More
SQ
08/17/2020
On google
Shanuqie Q.
Love the pizza. Love the place. Love the food. Today however was an absolute exception. We are there with my sister and we are greeted by the pizza staff who are ARGUING their mouths off. Vulgar words and profanity. Never had I experience like this. That bald kid and the guy with the glasses were going back and forth like no tomorrow. At least do it behind closed doors. Needless to say our appetite was lost today. There needs to be more professionalism when approaching customers. I understand it's a pizza parlor but that scene was deff not needed! Will try again tomorrow
More
OP
08/17/2020
On google
Omar Pena
The service is great. The food is awesome, and always consistent.
jS
08/17/2020
On google
jessica Scurry
The best penne ala vodka hands down consistant recipe for the last 10 years both locations too...the one in oceanside is nice as well
More
MH
08/17/2020
On google
Marty Hastings
My wife and I wanted to stop to get a bit to eat before heading for home and ejoyed the food very much
More
CW
08/17/2020
On google
C W
Okay, they deserve the 5 stars. The pizza is good. BUT! The reason why I'm writing this review is to highlight their "grandma vodka pizza" which costs $28. Are they out of their minds charging $28 for that?? It was literally just some vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella on pizza dough. There's nothing mind blowing about the pizza, it's small, and tastes pretty good. But that's it! Save your money and get a regular grandma pie instead.
More
DP
08/17/2020
On google
David Preis
Great pizza, plenty of parking and seating.
MM
08/17/2020
On google
Milly Millz
Went there the other day with my little sister, and the Employees who makes the food were not wearing masks while preparing and making the pizzas (some did others didn’t) I couldn’t believe it, I can understand how it get hot in the kitchen but we’re in a pandemic. Safety first. Don’t get me wrong I love the food but just seeing them not caring and having the masks as a chin guards just isn’t right. The girls who works there were wearing maskS and did a good job. The tall old man with the mustache and glasses was literally making pies of pizzas and was not wearing a mask. MIND BLOWN. Unfortunately I will not be going back there bc what I saw, and I’ve been going there since I was 13. Very unfortunate. Again, we’re in a pandemic wearing mask is very important especially working in a restaurant preparing food for others.
More
eo
08/17/2020
On google
eli oliveras
Food is always great and tasty.
TH
08/17/2020
On google
Tara Hoffman
Great customer service Morgan is awesome! He always personalizes the experience!
DD
08/17/2020
On google
Diahann De Ruggerio
Delicious food and great service. They offer gluten free options as well.
BS
08/17/2020
On google
Bob Smith
When I was waiting outside for my order ,I was looking in the window and no one behind the counter was wearing a mask or gloves and they were gettingThe food ready . And making the pizza. I thought they should have been wearing proper mask and gloves. Kinda turnt me off
More
SM
08/17/2020
On google
Star Morris
They are always on point!Pizza is cooked just right when I ask for the special orders. Delivery guys always nice & dont wait to long for themMy favorite pizza shop now.😁
More
JV
08/17/2020
On google
Jackie V
We visit this pizzeria a lot, this time was on a Friday during Lent so of course it was packed! Luckily the wait was not long and we were seated within 15 minutes by the extremely friendly hostess/waitresses. The pizza is consistently delicious, whether dining in or ordering take-out/delivery. This was the 1st time we tried their pasta and it was equally as good. Lent = no meat Fridays so the two of us shared a personal pizzette and a pasta dish. We actually had to take some home because it was a lot of food.
More
JU
08/17/2020
On google
Joe Umberto
Good quality food , quick service and clean place .
MO
08/17/2020
On google
Mark O'connell
Very nice aesthetics and atmosphere. Very large and roomy inside; great for a full blown dinner. Pizza is top notch in my opinion and service is quick. Although their menu is not very clear and has limited options.
More
DK
08/17/2020
On google
Deborah Kelly
High quality food, worth the price
DB
08/17/2020
On google
Diane Barbera
Always great food and organized chaos at times!
NM
08/17/2020
On google
Nivia Matos
Food is always amazing. Owner and staff attentive. Spotless clean
08/17/2020
On google
Lonewolf
When you wanna get your eats on this is the place! Food is always on point,friendly staff and all around great service. Only downfalls...5-7pm crazy wait...,specialty slices should be much bigger for the price... otherwise good eats...Enjoy
More
CB
08/17/2020
On google
Charles Brown
They do it right. Get over there and get yours you won't be disappointed. And I always get a veal parmesan hero with extra cheese and sauce. I've been in New York all my life but I live in South Carolina but when I come home I know where to go. New York has the best pizza Chinese food Bagels and I can go on and on.
More
GA
08/17/2020
On google
Gregory Altfest
2 slice of neopolitan pie thin crust good sauce and cheese best on Deer park ave!
More
PS
08/17/2020
On google
P S
We love Pizzaiola. This is our favorite pace to go with the family. They have great pastas and of course, the best pizza.
More
CG
08/17/2020
On google
Christopher Goloff
There was plenty of parking because the supermarket was put out of business...as like many other stores have closed.... but...there food is 🚂🤗
More
JN
08/17/2020
On google
James Norberg
Holy Pizza!!! Born and bred in Long Island, currently a DC resident. Every single time I go back to visit, I make sure to stop here to get the best pizza in NY. The specialty slices are each separate slices of heaven, and the buffalo chicken reins supreme. Always friendly and quick. The sit down restaurant portion is an above average Italian kitchen, but the pizza is some next level stuff.
More
mj
08/17/2020
On google
mary jane wallen
Just had the Mothers day dinner and it was delicious, thank you guys for a great meal and thank you for being open with everything going on please stay safe and we will definitely be ordering again.😁
More
TJ
08/17/2020
On google
Tania Joseph
Pizza is always burnt on the bottom. I ask time and time again not to burn the bottom,the pizza comes to my door and guess what the bottom is burnt. Not only is it burnt it is also cold. How can burnt pizza be cold? Time for a new pizza place.
More
MG
08/17/2020
On google
Miguel Garza
I have yet to go to a pizza joint that makes the pies fresh and heats up the slices upon request that I didn't love. This place continues that trend and I loved the chix bacon ranch pizza in particular. Not quite what I think of for 'authentic NY style pizza,' but still enjoyed it regardless.
More
JR
08/17/2020
On google
J Romano
They have large portions, the food there is delicious. I enjoyed the lasagna, it was so big I had to take a piece home. Great staff, great experience overall and parking is available.
More
JB
08/17/2020
On google
James Biskoff
Went in the other day only to be treated extremely rude by the staff on the registers. Did not feel safe with everyone's masks on their chin. Especially the short kid with glasses. He literally handled my food with his hands full on. and then proceeded to handle every other slice with his hands on the counter. Gross gross Gross. I was so shocked, I threw out my food as soon as I left the store.
More
CW
08/17/2020
On google
Curtis Waymer
Very good pizza, curbside pick up, love the cauliflower crust!
AB
08/17/2020
On google
Astrit Buci
They make really very Delicious pizza !
AT
08/17/2020
On google
Anny Tsang
This place is a returning diner for me. I come here more for their pasta and coffee. Their coffee is always served with a piece of biscotti, a great combination together. A basket full of warm assorted bread. Today I ordered from their special menu Pasta Fanatico, spinach linguine served with roasted red pepper and asparagus, and grilled chicken strips in a creamy light Marsala sauce. A special dish that’s not in the normal menu. They change their special menu every week. I’m glad I tasted this one. One of the favorite, even by their waitress.
More
GP
08/17/2020
On google
Gary Priore
No doubt about it this place has good slices and it's very nice 👌 they treat you like you're more than a customer. Thanks Mo!
More
MJ
08/17/2020
On google
Michael J Lupia
Great food, great service!!! I’ve moved out of NB for quite some years now. Unfortunately I moved further out east and the lack of good pizza place really makes you appreciate what you had. Every chance I’m back in the old neighborhood I take my entire family to pizziola NB. Me, my wife and kids all love this place, not only for food but the friendly service. They remember my face and always nice and friendly to my kids. I would recommend this place to others.
More
TC
08/17/2020
On google
T Cool
The pizza is good...a bit expensive but good.The past 3 times I've been there...their heater above the door has been broken and makes a LOUD NOISE..very annoying.
More
RC
08/17/2020
On google
Richard Chu
We love the Calamari Arrabbiata there. It's a good two person portion and just add soup or salad will be a meal for 2.
More
AD
08/17/2020
On google
Anthony Dioniso
Good pizza. Prices went up since covid. Thx China.
jc
08/17/2020
On google
jennifer carr
First time back on LI and we came here.. so good.. so messy.
CT
08/17/2020
On google
Christopher Thomas
Love pizzaiola ,brick oven pizza ,awesome,pasta nights are the best and desserts are very good .
More
JH
08/17/2020
On google
Justin Himes
Great pizza in the west islip area. My go to for lunch or diner when im at work. Its hard to find a good slice in suffolk but this place does a damn good job.
More
AM
08/17/2020
On google
Anthony Mazzio
Food is absolutely great! The stuff Eggplant with fish is to die for only problem is they dont have it on the menu every day. That is the only reason I didnt give it a 5 star rating
More
cw
08/17/2020
On google
chris wood
Great food pizza and service
KW
08/17/2020
On google
Kenneth Wieczorek
Would definitely recommend trying this spot. Fantastic vibes, tasty food, awesome customer service. I recommend this place.
More
TR
08/17/2020
On google
Teresa Romanelli
Amazing Food! My parents are both off the boat Italian and this is the only place they like to eat. You MUST taste the Buffalo Pizza! I literally crave it!
More
NT
08/17/2020
On google
Nina Thomas
Food was good. Staff was great!